Ask around a board table and someone will warn you about the Employment Standards Act: six months of unpaid wages, personally, if the organization goes under. It is the most repeated liability warning in the non-profit sector, and for an Ontario non-profit it cites the wrong statute. Subsection 80(2) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 is explicit: the Act’s director-liability part “does not apply with respect to directors of corporations to which the Not-for-Profit Corporations Act, 2010 applies.” An employment standards officer cannot order you to pay a nickel.
That is not the same as saying the liability is gone. It moved. ONCA carries its own wage provision, and the two federal tax statutes never had a non-profit exception to begin with. For the roughly 58,000 non-profits and charities the Ontario Nonprofit Network counts in this province the real list of personal exposures is short and specific. It is also completely indifferent to the fact that you are not being paid to sit there.
Section 40 of the Not-for-Profit Corporations Act, 2010 makes directors jointly and severally liable to the corporation’s employees for up to six months’ wages for services performed while they sat on the board, plus up to twelve months of accrued vacation pay. Those are the same ceilings a business-corporation director faces. What changed is the route. Under subsection 40(2), the employee has to sue the corporation itself and come up empty — execution returned unsatisfied in whole or in part — or prove a claim in the corporation’s liquidation, winding-up or bankruptcy. Only then does your own wallet open.
| Business corporation director | Ontario non-profit director | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the wage liability lives | Employment Standards Act, Part XX (with the corporate statute behind it) | ONCA s. 40 only — ESA s. 80(2) switches Part XX off |
| Who enforces it | An employment standards officer can issue an order against directors personally | The employee must sue; there is no Ministry of Labour order |
| Preconditions | The insolvency and order events listed in Part XX | Judgment against the corporation with execution returned unsatisfied, or a claim proved in liquidation, winding-up or bankruptcy (s. 40(2)) |
| Ceiling | Capped by the ESA’s own limits | Six months’ wages plus twelve months’ accrued vacation pay (s. 40(1)) |
The practical difference is real. A wage claim against non-profit directors needs a lawsuit, a judgment and a failed execution — or an insolvency with a proved claim — before it touches anyone personally. Few claims for a few months’ wages survive that much procedure. The exposure that actually lands on non-profit directors is almost never wages. It comes from Ottawa, and Ottawa is under no such restraint.
If there is payroll, income tax, CPP and EI come off every paycheque before it is issued. If it fails to remit those amounts, section 227.1 of the Income Tax Act makes every director jointly and severally liable for the shortfall — and not just the shortfall, but the interest and penalties riding on it. Section 323 of the Excise Tax Act does the same for unremitted HST. CRA’s directors’ liability circular, IC89-2R3, is blunt about who that catches: corporations “for-profit, non-profit, or not-for-profit,” and directors “whether active, passive, nominee, or outside.” The retired teacher who joined the board to help with the gala stands exactly where a paid executive director stands.
The CRA has to exhaust the corporation first — a certificate registered in the Federal Court with execution returned unsatisfied, or a claim proved in the corporation’s bankruptcy or dissolution. After that, it can assess you for the full amount. One hard stop exists: no assessment more than two years after you last ceased to be a director. That rule makes the date on a resignation letter worth more than most people give it. Resign in writing, keep a copy, and stop acting the part — a former director who keeps signing cheques and chairing meetings may be assessed as a de facto director long after the paperwork says they left.
The defence is due diligence, and it is measured objectively: the care a reasonably prudent person would have exercised in comparable circumstances to prevent the failure. The circular is blunt: steps taken after the remittances were missed do not count. CRA’s own suggested measures are almost embarrassingly simple: a separate account for withholdings, regular reports from whoever runs the finances, and routine confirmation that remittances actually went out. A standing agenda line — remittances confirmed current — costs a board thirty seconds a meeting.
Section 43 of ONCA requires every director and officer to act honestly and in good faith with a view to the best interests of the corporation, and to exercise the care, diligence and skill of a reasonably prudent person in comparable circumstances. Those are, word for word, the duties a for-profit director owes. Volunteering does not dilute them. Nothing in ONCA discounts the standard for good intentions or an empty pay stub, and under subsection 43(3) no contract, by-law or resolution can relieve you of it. The board that approves a budget nobody read is in breach of the same duty a public-company board would be — the stakes differ, the standard does not.
Section 44 is the protection you actually control. A director who exercised reasonable care is taken to have complied — and reasonable care expressly covers good-faith reliance on financial statements that an officer or the auditor presented as fair, and on the reports of lawyers, accountants and other professionals. Reliance is a defence you build in advance. The treasurer’s report received, questioned and minuted protects you; the one waved through on a crowded agenda probably does not.
Section 46 lets the corporation indemnify directors and officers against the costs of proceedings they face because of the role, and advance defence costs along the way. The conditions are the ones you would expect: the person acted honestly and in good faith, and indemnity against a derivative action needs the court’s approval. A director who is cleared — not found by any court to have committed any fault — is entitled to indemnity under subsection 46(5), not merely eligible for it. Subsection 46(6) lets the corporation buy directors’ and officers’ liability insurance.
Then comes the subsection almost nobody reads. Under subsection 46(7), a charitable corporation may not buy that insurance unless it complies with the Charities Accounting Act or obtains a court order. The compliance route is Ontario Regulation 4/01. It lets the board buy D&O cover without going near a courtroom — if, before buying, it weighs the degree of risk, whether the risk could practically be reduced some other way, and whether the premium is reasonable against both the risk and the charity’s revenue. The purchase must not unduly impair the charity’s work, and the regulation requires records showing the conditions were met. Most charities I see buy D&O cover the way they buy office contents insurance: a renewal invoice, paid, no minute anywhere. The coverage will usually still respond; it is the spending of charitable property on the premium that nobody actually authorized. One paragraph in the minutes that walks through those factors is the difference.
Whether your corporation counts as charitable is its own question — under ONCA it turns on what your purposes are, not on whether the CRA has registered you, a distinction our guide to the non-profit/charity distinction takes apart in full.
The statutes reward boards that can show their work. Put a line on every agenda confirming remittances are current, and minute it — that is your due diligence defence, built as you go. Read the financial statements and ask the question you are half-embarrassed to ask; section 44 protects documented reliance, not polite silence. Resign in writing when you leave, and remember the CRA’s two-year clock starts when you actually stop acting, not when you stop attending. Put the indemnity in the by-law before anyone needs it. And if the corporation is charitable, make the D&O purchase a board decision with the O. Reg. 4/01 factors in the minute, not a line item nobody looked at. None of this takes an hour a year.
If you are still deciding whether to incorporate at all, our ONCA incorporation guide walks through the process itself, and the deemed-amendment rules covers what happened to corporations that never updated their documents after the old Act died. For the business-corporation version of this question, see personal liability for corporate debts.
Board seats at Ontario’s non-profits are unpaid. The statutes just never agreed to price them that way.
Not in general. An incorporated non-profit is a separate legal person, and its ordinary debts — rent, suppliers, loans — belong to it alone. Personal liability arises only under specific statutes: unpaid wages and vacation pay under ONCA section 40, unremitted payroll source deductions under section 227.1 of the Income Tax Act, unremitted HST under section 323 of the Excise Tax Act, and liability for breaching the duties in ONCA section 43.
No. Subsection 80(2) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 says the Act’s director-liability part does not apply to directors of corporations governed by the Not-for-Profit Corporations Act, 2010. The wage exposure comes from ONCA section 40 instead, and it is enforced by a civil action — not by a Ministry of Labour order.
Up to six months’ wages for services performed while the director was on the board, plus up to twelve months’ accrued vacation pay. The employee must first sue the corporation and have execution returned unsatisfied, or prove a claim in the corporation’s liquidation, winding-up or bankruptcy.
No. CRA’s directors’ liability circular IC89-2R3 states that the statutes do not distinguish between active, passive, nominee or outside directors, and that non-profit corporations are fully covered. An unpaid volunteer director can be assessed for the corporation’s full unremitted source deductions and HST, plus interest and penalties.
Two years from the date the person last ceased to be a director. The clock runs from when they genuinely stopped holding and acting in the office — a written, dated resignation matters, and someone who keeps performing director functions can be treated as a de facto director, which keeps the clock from starting.
A director is not liable if they exercised the care, diligence and skill that a reasonably prudent person would have exercised in comparable circumstances to prevent the failure to remit. The standard is objective, and the steps must come before the failure. Practical measures include a separate account for withholdings, regular financial reporting to the board, and minuted confirmation at each meeting that remittances are current.
Yes. ONCA subsection 46(6) permits it. A charitable corporation, however, may only buy it under subsection 46(7) — by complying with the Charities Accounting Act regime in Ontario Regulation 4/01 (the board considers risk, alternatives, cost against risk and revenue, and keeps records) or by obtaining a court order.
Yes. ONCA section 46 permits indemnification and advances of defence costs where the director acted honestly and in good faith with a view to the corporation’s best interests; indemnity for a derivative action requires court approval. A director who is cleared of fault is entitled to indemnity under subsection 46(5). The indemnity should be in the by-law before anyone needs it.
Twenty minutes, no charge — a straight read on where you stand.
Book a 20-Minute Call